Animal Experimentation: Opposing Viewpoints
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
- This article is about the second edition of Animal Experimentation: Opposing Viewpoints; for the first edition see Animal Experimentation: Opposing Viewpoints (2000); for the third edition see Animal Experimentation: Opposing Viewpoints (2004).
Animal Experimentation: Opposing Viewpoints is a book, in the Opposing Viewpoints series. It examines the philosophical and practical issues relevant to animal rights, especially in relation to animal experimentation: whether animals have rights; if animal experimentation is justified; how it should be conducted; and if scientists should pursue new forms of animal testing. It was edited by Helen Cothran.
It was published by Greenhaven Press (San Diego) in 2002 as a 202-page hardcover (ISBN 0-7377-0903-0) and paperback (ISBN 0-7377-0902-2).
| Chapter | Viewpoint | Author | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Why Consider Opposing Viewpoints? | |||
| Introduction | |||
| Chapter 1: Do Animals Have Rights? | 1. Animals Have Rights | Tom Regan | Excerpt from The Philosophy of Animal Rights. |
| 2. Animals Do Not Have Rights | Charles R. Pulver | Excerpt from "Will Animals Have Duties As Well As Rights?" | |
| 3. Animals Are Equal to Humans | Animal Liberation | Excerpt from "Human and Animal Rights". | |
| 4. Animals Are Not Equal to Humans | Damon Linker | Reprint of "Rights for Rodents" in Commentary. | |
| 5. Core Teachings of the World's Religions Support Animal Rights | Norm Phelps | Excerpt from "Why the Animals Need Religion" in Animals' Agenda, September/October, 1999. | |
| 6. The World's Major Religions Support Animal Experimentation | Seriously Ill for Medical Research | Excerpt from "The Major Religions on Animals in Medical Research". | |
| 7. Animal Rights Activists Are Terrorists | Cal Thomas | ||
| 8. Animal Rights Activists Are Not Terrorists | Jane Cartmill | Excerpt from "Animals Are Victims of Violence" | |
| Chapter 2: Is Animal Experimentation Justified? | 1. Animal Experimentation Is Unethical | Robert Garner | Excerpt from "Animal Rights and Wrongs" |
| 2. Animal Experimentation Is Ethical | Henry E. Heffner | ||
| 3. Animal Research Is Vital to Medicine | Jack H. Botting and Adrian R. Morrison | ||
| 4. Animal Experimentation is Unscientific | C. Ray Greek and Jean Swingle Greek | Excerpt from Sacred Cows and Golden Geese: The Human Cost of Experiments on Animals. | |
| Chapter 3: How Should Animal Experimentation Be Conducted? | 1. The Animal Research Industry Needs More Oversight | In Defense of Animals | Reprint of "Research Oversight." |
| 2. Animal Experimentation Is Sufficiently Regulated | Delmas Luedke | Excerpt from "Ethics of Using Animals in Research." | |
| 3. Experimenting on Nonhuman Primates Is Vital to Science | Southwest Foundation for Biomedical Research | Excerpt from "Primates in Biomedical Research." | |
| 4. Nonhuman Primates Should Not Be Used in Experiments | Coalition to End Primate Experimentation | Excerpt from "The Argument." | |
| 5. Dogs Should Not Be Used for Animal Experimentation | Animal Aid | Excerpt from "Betrayed: The Silent Suffering of Cats and Dogs." | |
| 6. Experiments on Dogs Have Led to Medical Breakthroughs | Foundation for Biomedical Research | Excerpt from "Dogs and Research." | |
| 7. Rats and Mice Should Be Included in the Animal Welfare Act | F. Barbara Orlans | Excerpt from "The Injustice of Excluding Laboratory Rats, Mice, and Birds from the Animal Welfare Act," Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, September 2000. | |
| 8. Including Mice and Rats in the Animal Welfare Act Would Hinder Research | Debra J. Saunders | Excerpt from When Rats Have Rights." | |
| Chapter 4: Should Scientists Pursue New Forms of Animal Testing? | 1. Genetic Engineering Can Cure Human Diseases | Kevin O'Donnell | Excerpt from "Biotechnology and You." |
| 2. Genetic Engineering Is Dangerous | Michael W. Fox | Excerpt from "Tooling with Mother Nature: The Dangers of Genetic Engineering." | |
| 3. Cloning Harms Animals | Andrew Breslin | Reprint of "Notes from a Brave New World". | |
| 4. Cloning Can Help Humans and Animals | Ian Wilmut, Keith Campbell, and Colin Tudge | Excerpt from The Second Creation: Dolly and the Age of Biological Control. | |
| 5. Using Animals as Organ Donors will Save Human Lives | Susan E. Paris | Excerpt from "Animals to Human Transplants Are Vital." | |
| 6. Using Animals as Organ Donors Puts Human Lives at Risk | Jonathan Hughes | Excerpt from "Exnografting: Ethical Issues." | |
| For Further Discussion | |||
| Organizations to Contact | |||
| Bibliography of Books | |||
| Index | |||